AUTHOR: Responder TITLE: Fact Checking The Fact Check DATE: 2/19/2006 08:28:00 PM ----- BODY:
Faiz, over at Think Progress writes the following about conservative criticism about Al Gore's recent speech in Saudi Arabia:
Earlier this week, in an attempt to shift attention away from Vice President Cheney’s hunting accident, the right wing attacked former Vice President Al Gore for calling attention to the round-up of Arabs and Muslims that occurred in the days after 9/11. Labeling him “seditious,” Michelle Malkin said Gore “slandered” America for stating that Arabs had been “indiscriminately rounded up” after 9/11.

On Tuesday, Karl Rove’s White House deputy, Peter Wehner, emailed Gore’s comments on background to reporters urging them to editorialize on the issue. On NBC’s Meet the Press, Tim Russert gave airtime to Paul Gigot, editor of the Wall Street Journal, so he could say this:

I think the remarks were notable. Because I think when you go to a country like that, particularly in the heart of Wahhabi Islam, and say we have indiscriminately rounded up Arabs in this country after 9/11 — first of all, I don’t think that’s true. I don’t remember us doing that.

While the right has been quick to politicize Gore’s remarks, they haven’t had the time to do a fact-check. Gore was merely stating what has been reported and well-documented over the past few years:

Even some government officials are worried. In a secret meeting of top Justice Department officials hours after the attacks, then-immigration chief James Ziglar rebuked those in the room for proposing a “roundup” of Arabs and Muslims. “I’m not going to be part of this if we’re going to do things that blatantly violate the law,” Ziglar declared, according to people there. [Knight Ridder, 6/15/03]

The Census Bureau’s decision to give to the Department of Homeland Security data that identified populations of Arab-Americans was the modern-day equivalent of its pinpointing Japanese-American communities when internment camps were opened during World War II, members of an advisory board told the agency’s top officials Tuesday. “This for the Arab-American community is 1942,” said Barry Steinhardt, a civil liberties lawyer and member of the panel, the Decennial Census Advisory Committee. “Thousands of Arab-Americans have been rounded up and deported.” [New York Times, 11/10/04]
First of all, let's make something clear: These people were not 'rounded up' simply because they were Arabs. They were rounded up because they were here illegally. Faiz should also think to use more reliable sources than James Ziglar. People were quick to point out Michael Brown was not qualified to be head of FEMA. They should know that Ziglar was perhaps even less qualified to run the INS. You can read more about his useless tenure here. And let us not forget the true criticism of Al Gore's speech. He gave a speech in a foreign country and used the opportunity to bash America. He also gave this speech before an audience made up largely of Saudis, who in case people forget, was the home country of 15 of the 19 9/11 hijackers. He did this while having his speech funded in part by members of Osama bin Laden's family. Gore's actions were irresponsible, and considering they were in part, nonsense, makes it even moreso.